Minecraft Theories/Game Theory: The Tortured Ghosts of Minecraft (Minecraft Allay)
Game Theory: The Tortured Ghosts of Minecraft (Minecraft Allay)

Game Theory: The Tortured Ghosts of Minecraft (Minecraft Allay)

The Game Theorists14 minJul 16, 2022
10 chapters
  • Introduction and Sponsor Segment(0'002'00)
    The Theorist mobile is restored to its former glory, but encounters an unexpected interaction with the Allay mob, which provides a cell phone instead of car insurance.
    • GEICO has been saving people money for over 85 years • Bundling home and car insurance policies can save hundreds of dollars • Protection through comprehensive coverage allows peace of mind
    The host expresses readiness to explore lore theories about ancient builders in Minecraft.
    Introduction to Game Theory and announcement of the episode's focus on the newly introduced Allay mob from the Wild Update.
  • Wild Update Context and Allay Introduction(2'003'50)
    • The Warden contains spirits of five children • Warden was summoned by ancient builders to defeat the Wither • Ancient cities are forgotten structures built by ancient builders
    • Mangrove biomes with intricate tree formations • Frogs that consume slime and magma to produce light • Other unexplored content from the Wild Update
    The Allay is the 2021 mob vote winner that supports players by gathering resources. When given an item, it picks up more of that same item from the surrounding area.
    The Allay is deep-rooted in Minecraft's lore, confirming previous theories about other mobs while opening new questions about the game's dark, disturbing world.
  • Visual and Audio Connections Between Allay and Vex(3'505'50)
    The Allay bears a striking visual resemblance to the Vex mob, suggesting a deeper connection beyond appearance.
    • Vex are creatures made of souls, not flesh • Both Allay and Vex glow in dark environments • Multiple voices can be heard within Vex audio files, suggesting multiple souls
    The Allay's chortles sound very similar to voices heard in Vex shrieks, confirming an auditory connection between the two mobs.
    Vex means to anger or worry, while Allay means to relieve or alleviate, positioning them as opposite forces like an angel and devil.
  • Evoker Experimentation Theory(5'507'45)
    Evokers are experimenting with life and death, using souls to create horrifying monsters. Allay are captured and corrupted to create the Vex through soul manipulation.
    • Allay are found caged in pillager outposts and woodland mansion jail cells • One to three Allay appear per cage, matching the number of voices in Vex audio • Evokers gather these spirit creatures in groups for experimentation
    The Allay are not merely backstory for Vex but serve their own purpose, raising questions about their true origins and why they help players.
    Surface-level connections need exploration to understand the true history and nature of the Allay.
  • Origins: From Wisps to Allay(7'458'35)
    The Allay was originally designed for the 2020 Nether Update but was removed before implementation, later reintroduced as a mob vote candidate in 2021.
    • Originally called Wisps, not Allay • Designed as small cues leaving trails of blue flame • Blue fire connection made sense for Nether Update inclusion • Based on folklore depictions of wisps as ghostly lights or flames
    In folklore across regions, wisps are consistently depicted as spirits of the dead, which would fit the Nether but created lore complications.
    Adding soul-based mobs to the Nether would complicate the soul sand and soul soil ecosystem, making the Overworld a better fit for the Allay's introduction.
  • The Allay as Spirits of the Dead(8'359'45)
    The Allay's head design mirrors Steve's hairline and ear placement, suggesting a visual connection to the player character and the ancient builders.
    The Allay are the spirits of those who came before us, specifically the ancient builders who once inhabited this world.
    Mojang incorporated Steve's key visual features into the Allay as shorthand to indicate these creatures are connected to players and our world's history.
    The Allay is not a manifestation of the player's death, but rather evidence that the Allay are linked to humanity and our role in this world.
  • The Bond Between Player and Allay(9'4511'15)
    Unlike taming wolves and cats through feeding, the Allay forms a magical connection with the player by receiving a single item, not through food.
    • Allay have unique sounds labeled 'yearn' reflecting an intense longing for items • This craving suggests they need items for unfinished purposes • They desperately want to complete what they started
    The Allay are spirits of ancient builders desperate to finish their monuments and cities. They cannot accomplish this alone and require the new generation of builders to continue their legacy.
    When players give items to Allay, the spirits recognize them as descendants and willingly help gather resources to further the creative vision started by the ancients.
  • Enderman Connection and World Interaction(11'1512'15)
    The Allay can interact with the Minecraft world by picking up items, dropping them at note blocks, and engaging with the environment—a rare ability among mobs.
    • Enderman can also pick up and interact with blocks • Both mobs are theorized to be ancient builders • Enderman evolved over centuries while trapped in the End
    While Allay are trapped as spirits, Enderman represent the physical evolution of ancient builders who adapted to survive in the End dimension.
    The Allay's ability to handle objects confirms their connection to the ancient builders and their human-like capacity to manipulate their world.
  • Music, Memory, and Melancholy(12'1513'00)
    The Allay dances when within range of a jukebox with a music disc playing, showing a fondness for music that hints at deeper memories.
    Disc Five contains 23 seconds of music randomly inserted into the middle of a music disc owned by ancient builders in their ancient cities.
    Hearing music triggers the Allay to dance, reminding them of happy times when they were alive and dancing in the world they themselves built.
    The dancing Allay represent lost ancient builders reliving precious memories, making this a poignant moment for those who understand the game's true story.
  • Conclusion and Final Sponsor Message(13'0014'18)
    The Allay are tortured spirits of the ancient builders, yearning to complete their unfinished works and finding purpose in helping modern players continue their legacy.
    Minecraft is a game with a dark, disturbing world filled with trapped spirits and forgotten histories, where cheerful building hides a tragic past.
    • Just as the Allay provides needed materials, GEICO provides needed insurance • Host shares personal experience of changing car insurance through GEICO • Bundling policies saved money on multiple vehicles
    Dance on, Allay. Remember those long lost days. And for viewers: remember this is all just a theory, a Game Theory.