Minecraft Theories/Game Theory: Minecraft, Stop Using Diamonds!
Game Theory: Minecraft, Stop Using Diamonds!

Game Theory: Minecraft, Stop Using Diamonds!

The Game Theorists14 min8 août 2020
discover netherrite a powerful new material that makes diamond look like cobblestone
7 chapitres
  • Introduction to Netherite and Diamond's Fall from Grace(0'002'41)
    The Nether update introduced Netherite, a new ore that is superior to diamonds in every way, making it stronger and more durable than diamond gear.
    • Diamonds have been Minecraft's uncontested champion for 10 years • They defined the game's visual style and were the ultimate mining achievement • No significant new ore had challenged diamonds since Emerald in 2012
    The official update statement declared that Netherite makes diamond look like cobblestone, dethroning diamonds as the top-tier material.
    Despite Netherite's superiority, there's an even better material that has been overlooked since the game's beginning.
  • Why Diamonds Are Prized: Hardness vs Reality(2'415'04)
    Diamonds are marketed as super rare and super valuable, but this is largely artificial marketing and limited supply by the diamond cartel.
    • Diamonds are the hardest material on Earth with a rating of 10 on the Mohs hardness scale • The word diamond originates from Greek meaning unconquerable • Some synthetic materials like wurtzite boron nitride can be harder under laboratory conditions
    Diamond tools are used in industrial drilling and mining to cut through hard rock surfaces due to their extreme hardness and high melting point.
    The jewelry industry successfully marketed diamonds as forever stones, making them the ultimate symbol of love and value.
  • The Critical Flaw: Hardness vs Toughness(5'046'41)
    Hardness and toughness are inversely related scientific properties. Hardness is resistance to deformation, while toughness is resistance to fracturing when force is applied.
    • Glass is harder but plastic is tougher • A plastic bottle bounces when dropped but a glass bottle shatters • The harder something is, the more stiff and easier it is to shatter
    Diamond is surprisingly easy to break with basic hammers despite its hardness. Less than 5 pounds of force can shatter a diamond.
    When diamonds deform, everything shatters at once, making them terrible for applications requiring durability.
  • Why Diamond Tools Fail in Minecraft(6'418'46)
    • Trees are chopped, not sawed, requiring impact force not cutting force • A typical axe swing delivers about 80 pounds of force • Since less than 5 pounds of force shatters diamond, the axe head will break, not the tree
    Mining involves smacking rocks with pure diamond, which shatters easily. Real-world industrial drilling works by rubbing against diamond like sandpaper, not smashing it.
    • Arrows travel at 225 feet per second with enough kinetic force to damage armor • Diamond cannot deform or dent without breaking • Any force strong enough to bend diamond will shatter it completely
    Diamond tools and armor were never actually good for Minecraft, despite being the game's most sought-after material.
  • Netherite: A Flawed Solution(8'4610'37)
    Creating Netherite equipment requires diamond equipment first, suggesting a diamond-Netherite composite that fuses both materials stronger.
    • Metals can form alloys but diamond cannot bond easily with other materials • Diamonds are chemically unreactive, which is good for jewelry but terrible for mixing • This prevents making diamond less brittle through alloying
    Netherite armor is likely just diamond armor with a coating of Netherite, explaining the color change from sparkly blue to dull.
    • A Netherite coating doesn't eliminate diamond's brittleness • The diamond layer will crack if the coating bends • This makes Netherite armor potentially more dangerous than diamond alone
  • The Real Solution: Iron and Steel(10'3712'04)
    Gold has high toughness as a soft metal but low strength due to how easily it bends, making it unsuitable for tools and armor.
    Iron performs well on both strength and toughness scales. It's not too soft like gold but doesn't break easily like diamond, making it the actual best ore choice.
    • Adding carbon to iron creates steel, an even stronger material • Coal exists in Minecraft as a lump of carbon • Flint and steel already prove steel exists in the Minecraft universe
    The best tool or armor material must be both strong and tough, resisting stress before deforming while also resisting fracturing after being cracked.
  • Conclusion and Call to Action(12'0414'32)
    True loyalty should be to real science over game mechanics. A scientifically accurate crafting system would make steel accessible and stronger than every other ore.
    Stop using diamonds on tools and armor. Use diamonds on hoes instead, as originally suggested.
    • Honey is a free browser plugin for finding coupons and deals • Automatically scans the internet for savings across retailers like Lowe's, Target, and GameStop • Game Theorists using Honey's link have found over 3.1 million dollars in savings
    But hey, that's just a theory, a game theory.