Psychologie/Pushing The Limits Of Extreme Breath-Holding
Pushing The Limits Of Extreme Breath-Holding

Pushing The Limits Of Extreme Breath-Holding

Veritasium18 min30 sept. 2023
15 chapitres
  • Introduction and Challenge Setup(0'000'46)
    Brandon Birchak, a world expert in breath work, will hold his breath for the entire video while the camera continuously records him in a tank.
    Viewers are warned not to attempt this at home as Brandon is a professional. Derek will document how breath-holding works and learn techniques to extend his own breath-holding time.
    Derek failed his first swimming level because he refused to put his head underwater, making this challenge particularly daunting for him.
    A continuous shot of Brandon holding his breath will run on the right side of the video throughout the entire presentation.
  • The Biology of Breathing and Oxygen(0'461'54)
    All human cells need oxygen to survive. Oxygen reacts with glucose to produce ATP, the molecule that delivers energy where needed in cells.
    • Breathing happens without conscious thought under the autonomic nervous system • At rest, humans breathe about 12 times per minute • Breathing rate automatically increases during exercise
    Chemoreceptors in the carotid arteries and brainstem detect CO2 levels. Increasing CO2 makes blood more acidic, which is the main feedback mechanism that regulates breathing.
    The only known chemoreceptors for low blood oxygen are in the carotid arteries, and these play a smaller role in breathing regulation compared to CO2 sensors.
  • The Hyperventilation Trap(1'542'37)
    Hyperventilating before going underwater expels a lot of CO2, making the blood more alkaline, which is a very bad idea for breath-holding.
    Hyperventilation does not actually increase the amount of oxygen in the blood, which is limited by oxygen concentration in the air and the number of red blood cells.
    With alkaline blood, more CO2 must be produced before chemoreceptors signal the need to breathe, meaning more oxygen is consumed.
    The brain can run out of oxygen and lose consciousness underwater before the body even gets the urge to breathe, potentially resulting in drowning.
  • Optimizing Breath-Holding: The Two-Sided Equation(2'373'43)
    • Maximize the amount of oxygen in your body before starting • Minimize CO2 levels before the hold
    Reduce the rate at which oxygen is used up during the breath hold.
    BOLT stands for Body Oxygen Level Test. It measures the number of seconds you can hold your breath before feeling the first urge to breathe after a normal breath.
    • Some people are naturally better at holding their breath • Lung capacity ranges from 4-6 liters for most people, but some people have 10-liter capacity • Larger lungs hold more air and oxygen
  • Physical Training and Lung Expansion(3'435'05)
    Derek achieved a 40-second BOLT score at the beginning of training with Brandon.
    Stretching can help expand lung capacity. Specific stretching techniques include 90-degree chest stretches and exercises at half lung volume.
    The ideal physique for breath-holding is someone tall and skinny with plenty of lung capacity but not too much tissue to consume oxygen.
    After taking a full deep breath, you continue to take little sips of air, packing it in on top. Brandon demonstrates packing about 20 additional packs of air.
  • Reducing Oxygen Consumption Through Relaxation(5'055'47)
    • Since muscles use oxygen to contract, being relaxed is very important • A full body muscle check ensures nothing is engaged during the breath hold
    Brandon sometimes does active performances during breath-holds, but moving around uses oxygen faster, reducing the total duration he can hold.
    Mental and neuronal activity uses oxygen, so the goal is to preserve as much as possible. When the body is not moving, the brain uses 80% of the body's oxygen consumption.
    • Use a mantra to keep cycling thoughts and avoid random thinking • Give yourself something short and memorable to repeat • This can add 20-30 extra seconds toward the end of the breath hold
  • The Mammalian Dive Reflex(5'477'22)
    All mammals have a physiological adaptation called the mammalian dive reflex that helps us survive when submerged in water.
    • The trigeminal nerve in the face detects coolness of water • This triggers a series of survival responses in the body
    • The heart beats slower, decreasing the rate blood and oxygen are circulated • Blood vessels in extremities constrict, confining blood to vital organs and brain • This ensures enough oxygen reaches the brain to stay conscious • Hands may turn pale during extended breath holds due to lack of blood flow
    The spleen releases extra pre-oxygenated red blood cells into the bloodstream, increasing the available supply of oxygen.
  • Mental Strategies and Coping Techniques(7'228'40)
    • Use an alphabet exercise where you think of gratitude for each letter • The more you practice, the better you become at generating compassion and gratitude • This creates a very relaxing mental state
    During very long breath holds, Brandon describes not thinking about anything, feeling on cloud nine, and experiencing a psychedelic-like sensation between 5-15 minutes.
    The urge to breathe is your body lying to you. You do not actually need to breathe when the urge first appears; you have plenty more time.
    Understanding that you have about 4-5 minutes after the urge to breathe before any danger helps you stay relaxed and continue the hold.
  • Derek's Training Progress(8'4010'52)
    • Derek achieved 1 minute in first attempt • 1:30 in second attempt • 1:45-1:50 in third attempt
    Brandon recommended breathing at a set rhythm: 5 seconds in through the nose, 5 seconds out through the stomach, without engaging any muscles.
    • Derek used alphabet animals as a distraction technique instead of gratitudes • He also sang nursery rhymes from his children • Both methods helped gently distract the mind without being too cognitively demanding
    Derek achieved 2 minutes and 36 seconds by the end of training, significantly surpassing his initial 40-second baseline.
  • Physiological Verification and Mammalian Response(10'5213'30)
    • Derek's average heart rate was 72 beats per minute • During the breath hold, it dropped to 48 beats per minute • Derek noted this is lower than his sleeping heart rate
    Derek emphasized that the psychological aspect is the hardest part. The challenge is learning to distract and calm your mind when experiencing something unusual and uncomfortable.
    Having a knowledgeable and experienced guide like Brandon made a significant difference in successfully extending breath-hold duration.
    Derek reflected that he likely has never held his breath for 2.5 minutes in his entire life before this training session.
  • Advanced Techniques: Altitude and Pure Oxygen(13'3014'50)
    • Spending time at high altitude or in low oxygen chambers triggers the body to create more red blood cells • This increases oxygen carrying capacity • The chamber in the video was set to simulate 5,000 meters altitude
    Breathing pure oxygen beforehand can dramatically extend breath-hold duration beyond regular air limits.
    • Brandon's record for non-oxygenated breath hold is 10 minutes • With pure oxygen, Brandon has held his breath for 23 minutes • Branko Petrovic holds the record for regular air at 11 minutes 54 seconds • Budimir Sobat holds the pure oxygen record at 24 minutes 37 seconds
    Breathing pure oxygen is dangerous if you don't know what you're doing, especially for free divers. Oxygen toxicity risk increases significantly at depths beyond 5-6 meters.
  • Brandon's Record Attempt with Pure Oxygen(14'5015'15)
    Brandon went through a lengthy breathe-up process involving multiple breathing stages, with the final part involving breathing pure oxygen and packing in the last few gulps.
    Even with pure oxygen and optimal techniques, remaining submerged for an extended time isn't easy. Brandon held his breath for 17 minutes during this video attempt.
    • First few minutes: focused on retaining heavy lung pack and not losing air through the epiglottis • 5-15 minutes: super relaxed with sense of falling and euphoria • After 15 minutes: CO2 encroaches and requires fighting breathing mechanisms
    • CO2 has a slight narcotic effect • High CO2 causes loss of sense of time • The urge to breathe increases dramatically, then suddenly plummets dangerously
  • Underwater Performance and Artistic Integration(15'1516'07)
    With his wife, Brandon has pioneered the first active underwater performance that lasts 10 minutes, combining choreography with breath-holding.
    • Choreographing and directing underwater is different from normal work • Communication is limited by the underwater environment • Setting choreography to music while the performer is underwater adds complexity • Coordinating with aerial dance above water while managing underwater performance below
    This project is unprecedented, so they're literally writing the book as they go. They have to take risks to make something this extraordinary work.
    The performance dances on the line between what's possible and what's safe, continuously testing how far they can push the human body and artistic vision.
  • Physical Sensations and CO2 Narcosis(16'0717'17)
    The urge to breathe starts as a light sensation in the chest or lower diaphragm area.
    • As time progresses, convulsions develop • The urge to breathe keeps increasing • CO2 has narcotic effects that cloud judgment
    High CO2 causes you to lose sense of time completely. You have no idea how fast time is passing. The urge to breathe suddenly plummets, creating a false sense of being fine when your body is actually in danger.
    When the urge to breathe suddenly drops due to CO2 narcosis, you must pull the plug and breathe immediately, as this is when the body is most at risk despite feeling fine.
  • Extended Hold Mental Experience(17'1718'27)
    • First few minutes involve retaining the heavy lung pack • Preventing the epiglottis from opening or losing air • Keeping all other muscles calm while engaging only the necessary muscles
    • Between 5 and 15 minutes: super relaxed and euphoric • Sense of falling while fully conscious • A meditative, transcendent mental state
    • After 15 minutes: CO2 encroaches significantly • Must focus intensely on fighting breathing mechanisms • Active battles with diaphragm, intercostals, and epiglottis fluttering
    Brandon can physically feel his blood becoming acidic. The sensation is exactly like the urge to breathe. With practice, you get used to this extreme sensation.